Taxing Unrealized Capital Gains?
September 3, 2024
It would shake the markets.
——-
A tax proposal has been floated to tax unrealized gains. This refers to taxing the increase in the value of assets that have not yet been sold. Unrealized gains occur when an asset—such as stocks, real estate, or other investments—increases in value, but the owner hasn’t yet sold the asset and “realized” the profit.
Key Points of Proposal:
1.Current System: As of now, taxes on investments are typically applied only when gains are realized, meaning when the asset is sold, and the profit (or gain) is realized as income. Unrealized gains, where the value of an asset increases but isn’t sold, are not taxed.
2. Proposal Motivation: The idea behind taxing unrealized gains is to target wealthy individuals who often hold onto their investments and see their wealth increase significantly without selling assets. By holding assets instead of selling them, they defer paying capital gains taxes indefinitely, potentially avoiding taxes altogether if they pass on the assets to heirs with stepped-up basis.
3. Supporters’ Argument: Advocates for taxing unrealized gains argue that it would create a fairer system by ensuring that the wealthiest individuals, who often derive their income from investments, contribute more to public revenue. They believe this could help reduce income inequality, as currently, wages are taxed annually, while some large forms of wealth growth are not.
Overall, a tax on unrealized gains would be a significant departure from the current tax system and would require a fundamental change in how wealth and income are taxed. We cannot stress how bad of an idea this is and even if it is initially only targeting the ultra rich it would represent the proverbial “nose of the camel going under the tent.” It would only be a matter of time till it is targeted against every investor.
Why It is a Bad Idea:
1. Valuation Complexity: One of the biggest challenges with taxing unrealized gains is determining the accurate value of assets, such as stocks, real estate, or private businesses, which may fluctuate frequently or be hard to price. For example, private businesses or unique assets like art are not easily liquidated or valued with precision, making it difficult to fairly assess unrealized gains for tax purposes.
2. Liquidity Issues: Taxing unrealized gains could create a significant financial burden for taxpayers who might not have the liquidity to pay the tax without selling the underlying assets. This would especially affect those who hold non-liquid assets like real estate or shares of private companies. Forcing sales just to cover taxes could disrupt financial planning or long-term investment strategies.
3. Market Volatility: Unrealized gains are often temporary and tied to market fluctuations. Taxing them could lead to unfair outcomes where individuals are taxed on gains that may diminish or disappear in the future. If an asset’s value drops after a tax has been paid on its unrealized gain, taxpayers could end up paying taxes on “phantom” wealth they never actually realized.
4. Disincentive to Investment: Taxing unrealized gains could discourage long-term investments, as investors may become wary of holding assets if they are taxed on gains they have not yet realized. This could lead to reduced capital flow in markets and stifle economic growth, as people may prefer to move their capital into less productive but more liquid investments to avoid the tax burden.
5. Administrative Burden: Implementing a system to tax unrealized gains would require significant administrative resources, both for the government and for taxpayers. Taxpayers would need to keep detailed records of the fluctuating value of their assets, and tax authorities would face the challenge of auditing and verifying these valuations, creating bureaucratic inefficiencies.
6. Double Taxation Risk: Since unrealized gains eventually become realized (e.g., when an asset is sold), taxing them before they are realized could lead to double taxation. An individual could be taxed on the same gain twice: once when it is unrealized and again when the asset is sold, potentially creating an excessive tax burden.
7. Unfair to Long-Term Asset Holders: People who hold assets for long periods (e.g., retirement savings or family-owned properties) could be disproportionately affected by a tax on unrealized gains. Unlike short-term investors, long-term holders may see substantial paper gains over many years but not have the cash flow to pay taxes until they sell. This could penalize savers or those building wealth slowly over time.
Please keep in mind this information should not be considered as financial advice. Investment decisions should be based on individual research and consultation with a qualified financial professional. The value of investments can fluctuate, and past performance is not indicative of future results. Always consider your risk tolerance and financial goals before making investment decisions.
